Can improvisation be taught?

Can improvisation be taught?

There often seems to be an attitude in Australian jazz circles that, despite the global proliferation of jazz education, you can't really teach jazz. Education is important because it gives we musicians a source of income when gigs are scarce. Of course, when times are good, the teaching is the first thing we drop.

It can even a little bit humiliating to be a teacher:

“Where are you playing? “
“Oh, I'm mostly just teaching...”

This is wrong, of course. Jazz, and jazz improvisation, can be taught, and the job of teaching it should be an important part of being a musician.

In the past there was a golden age in which gigs were abundant, jazz was everywhere, and the young musician could learn on the bandstand through a kind of apprenticeship system. There were jam sessions, there were many entry-level gigs, and young players could get gigs alongside more experienced players.

Sadly, this is no more. The gigs have dried up and competition for playing work is fierce. Jam sessions occasionally come and go, but they are rare and fleeting. They are not serious gatherings of experienced musicians mingling with young up-and-comers. They are places where kids go and hear other kids, or even worse, they degenerate into a kind of shabby open mike session. Certainly not the learning experience of old. Nothing compared to, say, watching every tenor player in town coming down to try to best Ben Webster as he passed through with Ellington's band.

The apprenticeship system is mostly gone. What to replace it with? Jazz education.

The site of learning jazz has moved from the bandstand to the universities and schools. The great musicians of our time are commonly found on the faculty of a university, college, school or conservatorium. They are there passing on their knowledge, handing down the legacy of jazz, just as they used to on the bandstand.